lördag 6 maj 2017

Schrödinger: Do Electrons Think?



Schrödinger's equation is the basic basic mathematical model of quantum mechanics. It was first formulated for the Hydrogen atom with one electron in terms of a wave function $\psi (x,t)$ depending on a 3d space coordinate $x$ and a time coordinate $t$, with $\vert\psi (x,t)\vert^2$ representing electron charge density at $(x,t)$. Schrödinger's equation expresses stationarity of an associated energy functional and the ground state is defined as the charge density of minimal energy.  

Since the agreement between model and observation was perfect for Hydrogen, Schrödinger's equation was greeted as the most stunning triumph of the human mind since Newton's law of gravitation.

The generalisation of Schrödinger's equation to atoms with $N > 1$ electrons presented itself
as a formal extension into a wave function $\psi (x_1,...,x_N)$ depending on $N$ 3d space coordinates $x_j$, altogether $3N$ space coordinates.  But such a multi-d wave function could no longer be interpreted as a charge density in physical 3d space,  only as the probability to find at any given time electron $j$ at position $x_j$ for $j=1,...,N,$ as if the electrons as particles were randomly jumping around. This was coined the Copenhagen Interpretation of Bohr-Born-Heisenberg which took over the scene against heavy protests from Schrödinger and Einstein among others.

Schrödinger phrased his protest in many ways and in particular as the question do electrons think? Schrödinger argued that if electrons jump around randomly as in the Copenhagen Interpretation, then they cannot be viewed to think.  But if electrons instead in a deterministic way react upon forces so as to minimise energy, then they can be viewed to think in some sense. Schrödinger would thus give his answer as: Yes, electrons do think! as a protest to the randomness without thought of the Copenhagen Interpretation.

This connects to Descartes "I think and therefore I am (exist)". With the same logic for the electron, physical existence would be linked to thinking and so electrons do exist because they think and do not jump randomly without thought.

What do you think?          

5 kommentarer:

  1. Hello! I have been studying this Schrodinger lecture for many years. I am also a Biologist, just as Schrodinger. I think you may have misinterpreted his argument. He specifically cites "According to Sherrington, there is no boundary between the animate and the inanimate". if you look his manuscripts, you will see he has underlined this passage hard. And yes, we are automatons! There is no freedom, only need. You can choose how you will drink water, however you cannot decide not to drink water. Cheers!
    https://fedora.phaidra.univie.ac.at/fedora/get/o:168238/bdef:Asset/view#

    SvaraRadera
  2. Grow Your YouTube today without difficulty by using easy network that permits you to benefit 1000 free YouTube subscribers and views to your channel. For resolving outlook pii mistakes for [pii_email_37f47c404649338129d6], go to Askcoran now. To check your websites domain Authority navigate to DA PA Checker tool now on LetMePost

    SvaraRadera
  3. Another thing that will assist you in finding the ideal in-home care service provider is to set a budget. It's crucial to realise that in-home care services might cost anything from $100 to $500 per day.
    potomac home health Kensington, private in home care, home care agencies near me

    SvaraRadera
  4. نكهات فيب الرياض هي مجموعة شهية من التوابل والأعشاب والفواكه. توفر صلصات البهارات الحائزة على جوائز لدينا نكهات غنية ومميزة تمنحك "واو!" عندما يتعلق الأمر بالنكهة الرائعة ، فإننا نعني ذلك!

    SvaraRadera